Return of the Crimson Guard (Malazan Empire #2) ★★★★☆

crimson (Custom)

This review is written with a GPL 4.0 license and the rights contained therein shall supersede all TOS by any and all websites in regards to copying and sharing without proper authorization and permissions. Crossposted at WordPress, Blogspot & Librarything by Bookstooge’s Exalted Permission

Title: Return of the Crimson Guard
Series: Malazan Empire #2
Author: Ian Esslemont
Rating: 4 of 5 Stars
Genre: SFF
Pages: 732
Format: Digital Edition




I believe I counted Double Digit story threads going on, so I’m going to simply mention the overall highlights/plots.

The Crimson Guard vowed to fight the Malazan Empire and the Duke K’Azz was their leader. Due to the nature of their vow, the “Avowed” [the Guards who actually took the vow] cannot die of old age and are becoming superhuman. Once they do die, their ghosts stick around and act as messengers. The Guard was scattered after one particular encounter with the Malazans. Now they are beginning to come back together. The Duke is missing, so the next in command, Skinner, has taken command. But he’s apparently in thrall to the Broken God and so has his own agenda that subverts the Guards Vow. The Guard is split between those who follow Skinner and those who remain faithful to the original intent of the Vow.

This is all happening because various commanders and top dogs from the Malazan empire are sick of Laseen’s rule and are pulling away and allying themselves with local nationals. A splintering of the Empire that Kellenved began. Laseen comes to the continent with all the hosts she can muster to oppose the nationals. The Guard uses this to plan an attack on her to wipe her out. A phracking huge battle ensues.

A mad mage ends up opening a gate to Chaos and everybody comes together [sing it with me!] to stop him before the whole world is consumed. Laseen dies and Mallick Rel, introduced in Deadhouse Gates, becomes emperor. Treaties and peace negotians ensue and everyone is properly maudlin.


My Thoughts:

That synopsis was the shortest I could make it, honest.

This takes place several books later, chronologically, in the Malazan Book of the Fallen series by Erikson. However, characters from it, specifically, Mallick Rel, Korbolo Dom, Nil & Nether and even the reborn Coltaine, were relatively fresh in my mind from my read of Deadhouse Gates. That made connections MUCH easier to remember. Sadly, the reborn Coltaine gets just a couple of paragraphs before being sent back into literary oblivion.

Lets deal with my gripes first.

Once again, the deliberate with-holding of information about who a character is from the reader. It is not as simple as not telling us, but in several cases characters are thinking/talking about Mysterious Character X and it goes something like this:

“No, it couldn’t be. He’s dead!”

A veiled glance from Mystery Character X to the character talking…

“It IS him!”

Mystery Character X nods and walks away into the distance. Talking character is left in jaw dropping awe.

That makes me want to scream. It makes me feel like Esslemont is dancing in front of me going “Nyah, nyah, nyah! I know something you don’t know!” It is frustrating and probably my biggest gripe with both Esslemont and Erikson. They seem to revel in spitting in my face with hidden knowledge. Since this whole series is a re-read, I know this will keep on happening. But I don’t have to like it and I don’t.

On to the good stuff.

If you want complex plots filled with political, personal, religious and psychological threads, this is the schizzle. Like I said in the Synopsis, double digit threads being woven. Pay attention or you’ll get lost. Near the end, I DID get lost. Who was fighting who against who all became tangled up as new threats emerged and groups split and groups came together. Because there were Malazans on almost every side, it wasn’t even a Malazan Against Others story. It was a big messy group dynamics story.

I couldn’t race through this. I am finding that I need to slow down my reading to appreciate what I am reading at the moment instead of thinking about what I’m going to read next. This book was like walking through a mucky swamp; each step was an effort and you had to look right in front of you without looking at those distant mountains or you’d fall into a pit and never get out.

The munitions group, that coalesces around a Sergeant Jumpy is great. It made me laugh. It was a much needed comedic break because almost all the other story lines are of the Grimmest, Darkest Import. Everything else is weighed down by its own Self Importance. Just how they act and think is fun and I wish there had been a touch or two more of them.

Overall, I am satisfied with this re-read.

I had a lot more to say about this book this time around than I did back in ’10. Probably getting a bit garrulous in my declining years.



  1. Return of the Crimson Guard (2010 Review)
  2. Night of Knives (Malazan Empire #1)

16 thoughts on “Return of the Crimson Guard (Malazan Empire #2) ★★★★☆

  1. Oh no, I really don’t remember anything about this book! It’s embarrassing but I did not remember that Laseen dies! I am a bit worried about reading on now, I probably have to look for a really detailed summary. There’s no way I’m gonna read this again haha

    I might not even like the next book but I read somewhere that the series is getting much better so I’ll give it another chance.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I didn’t remember Laseen dying either.
      I like both authors because they really have almost the same voice.

      Did you not like these ICE [ian c esslemont] books because of the stories or what?

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I had problems with most of the characters. Apart from a couple that Erikson already wrote about, there was no one i was really interested in. I remember this Kyle(?) who was super boring.

        Unfortunately I hardly remember anything.. only that it took me a long time to finish and I had to force myself to read it at some point.

        I mean, I finished it and even planned to continue.. just because it’s Erikson’s world.

        It’s weird with this book..

        Liked by 1 person

  2. Ahahah at the evil dance from both authors. Sounds like those teaser moments serve well and keep you hooked to the book though! This whole universe continues to sound thoroughly amazing.

    P.S. Out of curiosity, do you plan on reading any 2017 new releases? Just curious if you had titles that you were excited to check out soon (like.. an insta-buy/insta-library type of deal).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. re: 2017 releases.
      That is a good question. Jack Campbell’s “Vanguard” is on my high priority list and there “might” be a couple of others as well. Honestly though, not much. I figure I’m about 18-24 months behind the curve, which actually works for me. Allows time for other reviewers to winnow the wheat from the chaff so I don’t have to take so much risk.
      Joel Shepherd’s Spiral Wars is also on my high priority, but the latest for that came out in Oct. ’16.

      So yeah, very few insta-buy books. Timothy Zahn used to be, but after his last couple, I now read them from the library and don’t have high expectations. Hope that helps.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Oh gee, thanks for thinking about it. I had a feeling that you preferred that method (waiting till you’re sure it will be worth it, based on other reviewers’ thoughts). Timothy Zahn! The guy with Star Wars books! Have you read all the expanded universe books for Star Wars? Would his Heir to the Empire be a good start for someone who wants to get more Star Wars in their lives; I mean is it the first book of the whole universe or is there a better place to start at? 😀

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Another reason I like waiting is because I want my review of Book X not to part of a flood. Michael fletcher’s book, Ghosts of Tomorrow, is a good example. Among the 60’ish people I follow, I’ve seen 6+ reviews of it. All within a 2 month period. I don’t want to be part of a bandwagon 🙂

          As for Zahn. I have read all the EU books, but none of the disney [new] eu books. Disney, with the wave of a pen, destroyed 25 years of EU writing and began their own. So nothing there is canon any more. That being said, even while his Thrawn trilogy is not canon, it is good Star Wars. Other than that, I’d stay away from the old EU [now known as Legends]. Zahn did write a book, Thrawn, for the new EU, so you could read that and his original trilogy and see how his style has changed.

          But if you do get into the old EU, Zahn’s Thrawn trilogy are the books that started it 🙂

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s